Bad Sign-Up Flows Cost SaaS Companies Customers Before They See the Product

With SaaS, you’ve got no second chance to make an entrance. Customers come through the door, sign up, and demand to be given instant access. Anything less and they disappear forever. A new Frontegg survey verifies just how much you stand to lose: 15% of SaaS users never come back after a less-than-perfect login experience. Frontegg’s First Login Benchmark Report surveyed 439 SaaS users to find out what they crave most from onboarding and why companies get it fundamentally wrong. What their findings reveal is just how little SaaS products need to do in order to earn user trust and, having lost it, how rarely the window of opportunity reopens.
^[1]

The First Impressions Aren’t Skin-Deep Quiz

Onboarding is not a handshake anymore. It’s a background check, trust evaluation, and product demo all in one. Nearly half of the users (48%) reported that they had abandoned a SaaS service due to registration taking too long. They would have already decided to return or not by the time they reached the dashboard. 36% churned on confirmation by e-mail step, and 21% insisted on instant access on sign-up. This go-fast strategy isn’t one taken in an attempt to compromise on security at all. It truly was the case, as speed and security did factor into 46% of those making their initial impression of a SaaS solution. Just 32% prioritized security over speed. That fast and stable combination is hard to find and nearly impossible to regain.

Why Login UX Can Make or Break Trust

Over half the users (58%) would not even subscribe to a SaaS application whose logon process did not look above board. That’s a harsh term, but it’s the best word to use for the gut-level feeling many users get when design, language, or interaction flow triggers a sense of unease. It isn’t rational, but perceptions govern. The majority of the irritations were old favorites. CAPTCHA was the most common top-of-the-list trust-breaking authentication process, seconded by convoluted multi-step identification verifications and cumbersome email verifications. The processes may lead to added security, but are most typical indicators of lack of design maturity or cumbersome flow if done ineptly. And the psychological impact is real. Twenty-one percent of the surveyed users admitted to rage-quitting onboarding by bailing on the entire process right there out of frustration long before even getting to experience the product. Those numbers show a bigger pattern. Login UX was once ambient. It then turned into the product experience itself.

The Long-Term Relevance of Login Interfaces

The most secure login features, most strongly linked in users’ minds with safety and professionalism, come as no surprise yet demonstrate a persistent gap between desired and delivered.

Two-factor authentication (2FA): 74% of users reported feeling safer when it’s enabled

Email confirmation: 23% consider it a sign of trust if executed well

Single sign-on and social login: 20% and 11%, respectively, value the convenience of them

These statistics indicate why intelligent design and simplicity are key when it comes to establishing user confidence. Users do not want the verification to be omitted completely, but rather quick, secure, and transparent.

Cost of a Bad Experience per Person

SaaS products have only one chance. 53% of the users would return to a SaaS product after a bad login experience, according to Frontegg, yet 15% would never return. Even if they do remain, they use it fractionally. Within a 30-day trial, over half (51%) had used 25 to 50% of the product features. That extent of selective adoption does more than limit the initial impression. It holds product stickiness and long-term satisfaction at bay. It is not just first-week churn. The negative sign-up impact extends into usage, word of mouth, and upsells.

What SaaS Teams Can Do Differently and Learn from

Understanding where users drop off is a crucial first step, but the tougher part is determining how to remove the friction causing the drop off, without implementing something that adds friction.

Here are some areas of focus for SaaS teams creating a login flow or reimagining one:

Removing friction without decreasing security. A fast way to access your app is important, but fast access will be no good and will not build trust if it amounts to a sketchy login. Users are willing to accept 2FA if it works properly; ineffective versions of Captcha or multi-step verification will likely drive users in the opposite direction.

Making verification frictionless. Email verification is a common drop point; real-time verification messages or progressive disclosure might alleviate friction at this delicate moment of onboarding for your users.

Treating the login UX process like the design of the core product. All screens and steps should feel purposeful for users. Confusion over where to go next or confusion over what the progress appears as can damage trust faster than slow-loading issues.

Testing sign-up as a potential new user. Internal teams often gloss over and ignore obstacles that new users frequently encounter. Testing, along with real user feedback, will provide the insights that metrics can miss.

The Big Picture: Trust Before Features

SaaS functionality and workflow take months or years to build. It will be useless if the users never even go beyond the front door. Frontegg data exemplifies the cultural pivot. Onboarding isn’t just getting users past the front door. It’s the first promise of value, security, and empathy. And when virtually one in every five users rage-quits on the first day and an additional 15% ghost after the one bum login, the margin of error basically does not exist anymore. For SaaS companies, that’s it. Good onboarding is not a nice-to-do. Growth. Retention. Reputation. Done. The virtual handshake is now. SaaS companies that wish to retain customers long enough to show them what they’re providing must trust customers immediately and often. That starts on the login page. The full First Login Benchmark Report results reveal more about why and when customers churn SaaS products prior to use. Get the full study here to read the recommendations and benchmarks.

Read next: How Many Prompts Can You Run on Gemini Each Day? Google Finally Sets the Numbers^[2]