Will ‘No Body Wants This’ Return for Season 3 After Season 2 Success on Netflix?

Would anyone really want to inhabit the swirling chaos of Joanne and Noah’s lives on Nobody Wants This? Netflix seems to have given these oddballs a stage, and fans have been bingeing the couple’s podcast-worthy squabbles with popcorn in hand. The series, part romantic comedy, part cultural collision, leaves hopeful viewers scanning the horizon for signs, a sabbatical, a cryptic Instagram post, or a rabbi’s blessing that might reveal what happens next.   

Everyone is buzzing about where the story will go, though official confirmation remains as elusive as Joanne at a synagogue board meeting. Guessing what comes next for this Netflix romance is officially a rabbinical-level mystery.

Nobody Wants This—sermons, sabotage or season three speculations

Erin Foster, the creator of Nobody Wants This, has hinted at possible developments but has not confirmed specific plans. Her mentions have ranged from the fun possibility of a cameo appearance alongside her sister Sara Foster, who is an executive producer on the show, to maybe, also entertaining the idea of temporarily stepping in for main characters like Joanne or Morgan if they were to take a break. However, as of now, the sisters have to live with the dilemma of being “not allowed to give any tea” as per Netflix’s conditions, they told PEOPLE. 

The show’s success is evident in both its first and second seasons on Netflix. The initial season, praised for its smart writing and authentic chemistry between the Iron Man-enlightened Kristen Bell and Adam Brody, received a 95% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and earned several Emmy nominations. The second season, premiering in October 2025, built on these strengths by deepening character relationships and maintaining audience engagement. So while sabbaticals and on-screen creator supervision and air about new characters swirl around as per PEOPLE, everything stays shut within Netflix’s room of non-negotiables for the perfect drop. ^[1][2]

If a rabbi and a podcast host can weather family drama, surely viewers can survive the wait for season three.

Netflix’s divine mysteries and streaming speculations is exactly what everybody wants

Nobody Wants This centers on the engaging relationship between Joanne Williams, an outspoken agnostic podcast host, and Noah Roklov, an unconventional American rabbi. Along with a strong supporting cast, including Justine Lupe and Timothy Simons, the show skillfully explores themes of interfaith romance and family dynamics. Its placement on Netflix allows it to reach a wide audience, pleased with its fresh take on contemporary love and cultural contrasts.

As fans await news of a possible third season, Nobody Wants This continues to captivate with its blend of humor, heart, and relevance. Erin Foster’s vague hints keep anticipation alive but leave much to the imagination. With its critical acclaim, remarkable cast, and thoughtful storytelling, the show remains a standout on Netflix, promising that any future season would be worth the wait. The curiosity about what may come next only enhances the show’s charm and loyal following.

Do you want a season three to pop onto your streaming scene? Or do you think Nobody Wants This? Let us know in the comments below!